Hire Movers in Shelter Island

Looking for the best local movers in Shelter Island? HireAHelper has been curating the highest-rated Shelter Island moving companies and day laborers in every city in New York for more than 16 years.

Compare the Top 4 Shelter Island, NY Movers

According to thousands of honest reviews in your area, these are the top-rated movers as of Saturday, November 9, 2024.

$125/hr

After 2 movers 2 hr min

A Plus Moving LLC

4.9 405 verified reviews

East Haven, CT

1,256 moves with HireAHelper

A Plus Moving LLC Profile Image
A Plus Moving LLC. is a family ran professional moving labor company dedicated to providing A+ customer satisf… read more

$119/hr

After 2 movers 2 hr min

Makin Moves

4.9 382 verified reviews

Rocky Point, NY

1,192 moves with HireAHelper

Makin Moves Profile Image
Makin Moves Inc. is proud to serve the Carolinas and surrounding areas the Since 2013, and we are now proud t… read more

$120/hr

After 2 movers 2 hr min

First Class Movers, LLC

4.6 118 verified reviews

New Haven, CT

450 moves with HireAHelper

First Class Movers, LLC Profile Image
Serving all of Connecticut · Fast & Reliable, Hassle Free Moving Services · Top Rated Professionals · We’ve go… read more

$90/hr

After 2 movers 2 hr min

Ready To Move

4.9 43 verified reviews

Middletown, CT

102 moves with HireAHelper

Ready To Move Profile Image
At Ready to Move LLC, we take pride in our dedicated team of professionals who are committed to ensuring the e… read more
Tell Us About Your Move

What Service Do You Need?

Shelter Island Mover Reviews

Len D from Ridgefield, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
A Plus Moving LLC Profile Image

Highly recommend this company. David and Julian were courteous,hard working and efficient

Reviewed on: 11/5/2024
Rebekah D from Myrtle Beach, SC
Reviewing: Makin Moves
(5 out of 5 rating)
Makin Moves Profile Image

Vinnie and his team worked hard to complete my job in a timely manner despite an unexpected staff call-off. They were very friendly and well organized.

Reviewed on: 9/30/2024
Gerriann J from Old Lyme, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
First Class Movers, LLC Profile Image

Great personalities, strong, very efficient with great problem solving skills that enabled them to fit everything we needed into the POD

Reviewed on: 10/3/2024
Aubrey G from Daytona Beach, FL
Reviewing: Ready To Move
(5 out of 5 rating)
Ready To Move Profile Image

We had 2 helpers for 2 hours!! They cleared a 26 box truck in such a short amount of time. Thank you you guys.

Reviewed on: 10/29/2024
Movers Unloading

Local Moving Resources for Shelter Island

HireAHelper compiles data from hundreds of moves in the greater Shelter Island area to share with you, so you can have accurate, up-to-the-minute timelines and prices for New York movers near you.

Avg. Shelter Island move books:
2 movers/hr.
Avg. Shelter Island move takes:
4 hours
Moving Truck parked in the street

Frequently asked moving questions in Shelter Island

When is it cheapest to move in Shelter Island?

January

Of all months of the year, the cheapest time to move in Shelter Island is January. Get your personalized moving quote.

What day is it cheaper to move in Shelter Island?

Monday

Monday is the cheapest day to move in Shelter Island.

The best time of day to move in Shelter Island is...

9 AM - 10 AM

People who save the most on their move in Shelter Island started it at 9 AM - 10 AM.

How far in advance should I schedule my appointment?

12 days

People in Shelter Island tend to book their move at least 12 days in advance.

How much do movers in Shelter Island cost?

$531

Hiring a moving company in Shelter Island costs $531 on average.

How long does moving in Shelter Island take?

4 hours

Shelter Island movers take 4 hours per job, on average. Check the best times to move in Shelter Island.

How many movers do I need for my move in Shelter Island?

2 movers

Most people moving in Shelter Island hire 2 movers to come out on moving day. Read more about hiring the right number of movers.

What size truck do I need when moving in Shelter Island?

16' Truck

Most people in Shelter Island need a 16' moving truck. Compare rental trucks and find your perfect size.


Advice for Moving in Shelter Island or Anywhere.

Because we know a little about moving, we've written some need-to-know articles that can help make moving in Shelter Island, or anywhere really, as easy as can be.

moving boxes of different sizes and types are stacked in the middle of a room
Too Big, Too Small, or Just Right — Find the Right Size and Type of Moving Box for Your Move
In a way, moving boxes can be considered the unsung heroes of a successful move. Quietly, they play a vital role in ensuring your belongings reach their new destination intact. But do the types of boxes you move with really matter? Yes, they can.  (Looking for where to get free moving boxes? Here’s our guide […]
Read more October 31, 2023
" style=
10 Charities Offering Free Furniture Donation Pickup
When it’s time to update your living room furniture or declutter your home, don’t just toss your old items into the trash. According to the EPA, Americans discarded a staggering 12.1 million tons of furniture in 2018, with a staggering 80.1% of it ending up in landfills.  On the flip side, you could join those […]
Read more December 01, 2023
a woman calculates the cost of a move with a calculator, surrounded by packed boxes
What’s the Cheapest Way To Move? A Guide for Thrifty Moving
Moving is a common part of life, whether you’re seeking new opportunities, downsizing, or just looking for a change. With the rise of remote work, there is even more flexibility on where to live. Recent data indicates that people are still moving, so the demand for moving services makes costs remain pretty steep.  Fortunately, moving […]
Read more September 06, 2024
elderly parents wave to their adult child and grandchild in a car
Empty Nesting: Downsizing and Moving to a Smaller Home
You’ve probably joked with your friends at some point about how great it’ll be to get your kids out of the house for good. But when that day actually comes, you might be surprised by the rush of emotions that take over. For years, you’ve spent a significant portion of your day with your kids. […]
Read more July 11, 2023
an illustration of a person in protective goggles looking at miniatures of two homes with price tags on them
Study: How Much Does Moving Cost in 2023?
Key Findings Based on our projections, the cost of moving in 2023 will be 2% lower than in 2022 Moving costs are 4% higher so far in 2023 than in the same period last year The average cost of a move is projected to peak at $421 by August 2023, 7% lower than last year’s […]
Read more July 05, 2023

Shelter Island Moving Statistics

Best Time of the Year to Move

A spinning icon meant to display that something is loading.

Best Time of the Week to Move

A spinning icon meant to display that something is loading.

Cost of Moving by Type of Help Needed

A spinning icon meant to display that something is loading.

How Long It Usually Takes to Move in Shelter Island

A spinning icon meant to display that something is loading.
HireAHelper Team PhotoOur HireAHelper Team

Why Do So Many People in Shelter Island Use HireAHelper?

Nobody understands moving in Shelter Island like we do.

HireAHelper curates local movers in Shelter Island that have MC#/DOT licenses and verified user reviews. After we help you easily book your movers, we're here 7 days-a-week to monitor your move for you, both online and with a REAL person over the phone.

And as if that wasn’t enough, we offer personalized insurance policies on every single booking through HireAHelper in New York, so you'll feel extra safe on Moving Day.

1,420 Shelter Island Mover Reviews

On average, movers on HireAHelper earn 4.8 stars out of 5.0 after 288,643 verified customer reviews

Lisa G from Oakdale, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
Heavy Foot Movers Profile Image

The two men who unloaded our POD were professional, helpful and polite. They worked well together and were very efficient. I would definitely use their service if needed again.

Reviewed on: 10/22/2024
Susan W from Middletown, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
A Plus Moving LLC Profile Image

Mike and Dave were amazing! On time, efficient and masters of the moving truck Tetris match!! Their friendly and courteous nature made this a stress free experience!

Reviewed on: 10/15/2024
Brittany P from Hamden, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
Heavy Foot Movers Profile Image

Eric & Ronin were fantastic! I would definitely recommend for any move. They were courteous and great workers. They fit my stuff into less space than expected and quickly. Sorry about all the stairs. Definitely 5 stars ??

Reviewed on: 10/9/2024
Rory S from Groton, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
Heavy Foot Movers Profile Image

I had Eric, Ron, and Robin today helping us out. They were efficient and helped get the truck as packed as we could. I wish I could hire them for unloading.

Reviewed on: 9/29/2024
Mike G from Coram, NY
(5 out of 5 rating)
Always Reliable Moving Specialist Profile Image

These guys were AWESOME!!! I was sooo nervous because I didn't think all my large furniture would fit in this container. These brothers came in and I showed them what I had and what I hoped can go in the container. They PACKED ERRRTHING!!! They even packed our 3 bikes! Yes, these guys are AWESOME. I took some of their business cards to pass them out to my friends! They are 10 STAR RATING! MIKE G.

Reviewed on: 8/26/2024
Anita S from Clinton, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
A Plus Moving LLC Profile Image

These guys were amazing! They arrived in time. Loaded my stuff into the van like Tetris masters! They were pleasant and worked hard. They even offered to help with something unrelated! Highly recommend!!!! Anita

Reviewed on: 9/4/2024
Sarah A from West Haven, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
A Plus Moving LLC Profile Image

These guys are top-notch! I booked them on short notice, and for a very difficult job. (I don't recommend doing what I did--it was kinda nuts), but they came through and got the move done anyway. They were friendly, respectful, and helpful. If I had to do another move in the same area, I'd 100% call them again!

Reviewed on: 10/16/2024
Jason and Katie S from Hamden, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
A Plus Moving LLC Profile Image

Outstanding job by Pop’s David and Mike . All three were very professional and listened to what we needed. They worked so well together and went above and beyond our expectations. They worked quickly and efficiently. All three worked very hard. I would absolutely recommend them and will consider them for any future work we need. A+++ for sure

Reviewed on: 10/9/2024
Sarah A from Clinton, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
A Plus Moving LLC Profile Image

I would give Anthony and Jorge more than 5 stars if I could. They were awesome. Showed up on time. Got everything done in the time allotted. Very kind and courteous and the most amazing packers I have ever seen.. We were unsure if we could fit everything in one truck but with their amazing packing skills it was not a problem. Highly recommend!!

Reviewed on: 8/21/2024
Gary S from East Lyme, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
Last Minute Movers Profile Image

The two gentlemen were hard workers. Started immediately and worked non stop until they completed the job. Because they completed the job in less than the 2 hour time frame, we had them load other items and well as move an elliptical trainer for us. They were very polite and accommodating .

Reviewed on: 8/22/2024
Michael R from East Haddam, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
A Plus Moving LLC Profile Image

David and Michael were outstanding. They worked diligently until completed. I could not give a high enough recommendation. Absolutely wonderful as both people and the work they performed. They were on time. Both respectful to my wife and myself. They had all proper materials. I would highly recommend them.

Reviewed on: 9/27/2024
Ann D from Groton, CT
(5 out of 5 rating)
Heavy Camp Movers Profile Image

Christian and Danny were amazing! They were professional, efficient and respectful of our home and our furnishings. They took an extremely stressful situation and made it manageable. I highly recommend them!

Reviewed on: 9/11/2024

Book Local Movers Today